We Are Not Free

Content Overview

Overall Content
Severity
4.6

Language

10.0/10

Alcohol, Drugs, Smoking

2.0/10

Intimacy, Sex, Immodesty

1.5/10

Violence, Weapons, Blood, Crime

7.8/10

Potentially Intense Themes

1.6/10

**As an Amazon associate I earn from qualifying purchases. 

My Opinion

“We could do everything right, and they’d still think we’re dangerous.”

4 out of 5 stars (4 / 5) Chee wrote this novel after interviewing her grandparents and many family members that were put into American camps for those of Japanese descent. The book started strong with details I drank in and couldn’t get enough of. 

The story follows 14 teens through their experiences before Pearl Harbor was bombed, to after they were released from the camps. A total of about 3 years. The POV changes but follows the same storyline. While it was interesting to hear the different views, I never felt very connected to the characters because I didn’t learn enough about them before the POV changed again. With 14 different voices, I got very confused who they were and even if it was a guy or girl talking.

The middle of the story lagged a bit. While in the camps, it went through their day to day life of school and work and play and it wasn’t enough to keep my interest. Then the POV changed to those that volunteered to fight in the war and I was instantly transfixed again. 

Ultimately this story brought me to tears. The trauma they endured was horrific. Fear ruled everyone; American, Japanese, soldiers and civilians. Because of that fear, people did stupid things. It’s not a part of history that I am proud of and it hurt worse when it talked of camps in my own state of Utah. I admired a lot of spirit that was put into these characters and especially those that fought for an America that did not deserve that loyalty. It’s a humbling story to read and I will never see that time period the same. 

Thank you to Goodreads for the giveaway win and to HMH Books for Young Readers for the copy in exchange for an honest review. This book comes out September 1, 2020.

We Are Not Free

Traci Chee

“All around me, my friends are talking, joking, laughing. Outside is the camp, the barbed wire, the guard towers, the city, the country that hates us. 

We are not free. 

But we are not alone.”  

Fourteen teens who have grown up together in Japantown, San Francisco. 

Fourteen teens who form a community and a family, as interconnected as they are conflicted. 

Fourteen teens whose lives are turned upside down when over 100,000 people of Japanese ancestry are removed from their homes and forced into desolate incarceration camps. 

In a world that seems determined to hate them, these young Nisei must rally together as racism and injustice threaten to pull them apart.

Excerpt taken from Goodreads.

Check Goodreads to see the book’s ratings. 

Detailed Content Review

Language 

F***- 21

H***- 17

S***- 41

A**- 18

B****- 6

D***- 46

Bas****- 3

Religious Cursing

J****- 5

Chr***- 1

G**- 34

L***-

Derogatory terms etc-

Jap

Nip (Japanese)

Ketos (Americans)

Ebi (shrimp)

Dirty nips

Stupid kotonk 

Alcohol, Drugs, Smoking

A man goes outside for a smoke.

A man smokes a cigarette.

Two young men smoke.

A man lights his cigarette.

Teens drink a bottle of sake. 

A young woman gets drunk and vomits. 

A man smokes a pipe.

A man smokes a pipe.

A young woman dreams of when her stepfather always smelled of sake. 

A young man carries a bottle of Jack Daniels.

A young man soldier (18?) steals bottles of wine to share.

Soldiers pass around cigarettes. 

A group of teens drink sake. 

Two women smoke cigarettes. 

Intimacy, Sex, Immodesty

*Minor LGBTQ+ aspects included*

Women and girls are forced to undress when they enter the camp. Many cover themselves with their hands. Two young women eye each other and one whispers, “nice kabochas!”

A young woman trips over two people and she realizes what they were doing in the dark. (Vaguely implies sex). She wonders if her boyfriend would meet her in the dark and kiss her?

A young woman kisses a young man. They kiss for hours until the sun comes up. He gives her a hickey or “love bite” on her neck. 

A young woman sees a young man kiss a young woman while pressed against a building. 

A young man and young woman kiss passionately. She wants to “do more” and they do but the scene ends and picks up again later. No details. 

A young man admits to loving another young man. 

Violence, Weapons, Crime, Blood

A group cornered a Japanese-American and told him they were going to get rid of him to help America.

Four men surround a young teen boy, threatening him. They throw him on the ground, kick him multiple times in the head and pull out a knife. They throw rocks at a man.

Two teens break into an abandoned noodle house. They break many items and throw things. They go looking for a fight and one punches a young man and four punch each other until sirens are heard. 

A man punches the person nearest to him, looking for a fight. People yell and he keeps swinging. He later charges a man and he punches his head in response. They punch back and forth then one runs. 

A young man remembers when people banged on their store windows with bricks  and painted “Go home Japs” on it.

An elderly man is shot by the fence. A young man is tackled to stop when he tries to help. 

Soldiers shoot bullets in the air and a young man gets trampled. 

A man gets kicked and beaten by two men. Young teens intervene and shout and throw a baseball at one. 

A mother slaps her daughter. 

A man requests 2 people attend a funeral but he’s requesting with a billy club in his hand. Many carry billy clubs. 

10 Caucasian soldiers are taken captive by 5,000 Japanese prisoners, cars are vandalized, one man is beaten. 

A young woman remembers when her stepdad “knocked her around.”

Young men find a broken baseball bat with blood on it and on nearby walls. Soldiers send tear gas into the streets. 

A stepfather used to hit his young daughter. 

A young man is arrested for being 5 minutes past curfew. The soldiers smack him on the head and “rough him up.”

A man lifts his head in a training exercise and is hit with bullets. When they take his helmet off, “brains everywhere.”

While running from artillery fire, a young man looks next to him and the soldier who was there is now on the ground with a bullet in his head.

A soldier shoots the enemy’s machine gun nest. There is a lot of blood. Many men are lost. No details. 

While evading the enemy, bullets are coming close to some young men, another runs out to distract them. One is hit, another goes to pull him to safety and there is a lot of blood. Grenades explode. The sound of artillery barrages is deafening and frightening. 

A grenade is thrown in a ditch of men. Bodies go flying out and one shoots one. A friend is shot, there are so many holes in him his friend can’t plug them all. One eye is gone. 

Legs are blown off by mortars, shot up my machine guns, skulls shot by snipers, tanks take out many. 

A soldier kills a man with his small knife then keeps moving. A man jumps on top of another man to protect him from shots and he is killed while on top of the man. 

A group of soldiers runs into enemy fire. Many are falling. One gets hit in the thigh and blood is coming out fast. He lays down and reminisces as he dies. 

A young woman slaps a young woman.

A mother slaps her child. 

Potentially Intense Themes

When the bombing started, a Japanese-American mom started burning all her Japanese momentos like the flag, so as to prove her loyalty to America. 

A Japanese-American businessman is taken away by the FBI.

People pin labels to their clothes or stores that claims their nationality isn’t Japanese.

The homes in the camp are horse stalls with army cots. No running water or furniture. 

A young boy runs away and many search for him. 

A young man picks up individual pieces of spilled rice out of the dirt because his family is starving. 

There are separate drinking fountains for “colored.”

There are a few chapters that take place on the field for soldiers. Battles, grenades, sounds, smells, getting shot at and more are talked about. 

Friends take a soldiers death very hard. They fall to the ground or punch walls and more. It’s very emotional. 

**As an Amazon associate I earn from qualifying purchases. 

4 Comments

  1. I think books like these are really important to get into the hands of YA readers! Great review!

  2. These hard hitting books seem so sad and I always try to avoid heavy topics in literature. I do think think they are important to discuss though!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*